About this home

Great investment opportunity in McSherrystown! Located at 516 Main Street, this duplex was remodeled in 2025 and features two units, both currently leased and generating rental income. The property offers updated interiors, spacious living areas, and functional layouts. With recent renovations and established rental income, this property is a great option for investors looking to expand their portfolio. Schedule your showing today!

Facts and features

Schools

• New Oxford Middle School

  middle · 7-8 · 4.9 mi

  7

• New Oxford Senior High School

  high · 9-12 · 4.9 mi

  6

• Conewago Valley Intermediate School

  elementary · 4-6 · 5.4 mi

  5

• Delone Catholic High School

  high · 9-12 · 0.2 mi

• Saint Teresa of Calcutta Catholic School

  elementary · PK-8 · 0.3 mi

• Conewago Township Elementary School

  elementary · K-3 · 0.4 mi

  7

Price history

• Oct 13, 2026 · Listed$275,000
• Apr 17, 1989 · Sold$50,000

Tax history

• 2026$3,823 tax · $144,300 assessed
• 2025$3,709 tax · $144,300 assessed
• 2024$3,445 tax · $144,300 assessed
• 2023$3,328 tax · $144,300 assessed
• 2022$3,233 tax · $144,300 assessed
• 2021$3,085 tax · $144,300 assessed
• 2020$3,017 tax · $144,300 assessed
• 2019$2,959 tax · $144,300 assessed

Home value

$237,400

• Cotality$237,400
• Collateral Analytics$206,000
• Quantarium$271,531

Where it is