About this home

A fantastic opportunity for investors and owner-occupants alike! This beautifully updated legal two-family home in Bay Shore offers the perfect combination of comfortable living and income-producing potential. Featuring approximately 1,800 square feet of bright, spacious living space, the property offers a total of 5 bedrooms and 3 full bathrooms across two separate residences. The first-floor unit, fully renovated within the past six months, features 3 bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms, while the updated second-floor unit offers 2 bedrooms and 1 full bathroom. Both units boast clean, inviting interiors with plenty of natural light and their own private entrances. A separate entrance to the unfinished basement provides additional convenience and potential. Outside, you'll find a spacious, well-maintained backyard with plenty of room for relaxing and entertaining, along with off-street parking. Conveniently located near Bay Shore High School, shopping, and major roadways. Whether you're looking to live in one unit while generating rental income from the other or add a versatile two-family property to your investment portfolio, this home offers an incredible opportunity. Two updated units, flexible living arrangements, and the potential to help offset your mortgage. Don't miss your chance to see it for yourself!

Facts and features

Schools

• Brook Avenue Elementary School

  elementary · K-2 · 0.2 mi

• Bay Shore Senior High School

  high · 9-12 · 0.3 mi

  6

• Bay Shore Middle School

  middle · 6-8 · 0.5 mi

  5

• Heritage Christian Academy

  elementary · PK-5 · 0.8 mi

• Gardiner Manor School

  elementary · 3-5 · 1.7 mi

  3

• Fifth Avenue School

  elementary · K-2 · 0.6 mi

Price history

• Oct 26, 2026 · Listed$700,000
• Oct 26, 2026 · Listed$700,000
• Oct 23, 2026 · Listing Removed$2,900
• Sep 24, 2026 · Price Changed For Rent$2,900
• Sep 12, 2026 · Price Changed For Rent$3,000
• Jul 21, 2026 · Listed For Rent$3,200
• Jan 28, 2021 · Sold$419,120
• Jul 10, 2012 · Listing Removed$1,094

Tax history

• 2025$10,497 tax · $29,000 assessed
• 2024$9,655 tax · $29,000 assessed
• 2023$9,655 tax · $29,000 assessed
• 2022$9,692 tax · $29,000 assessed
• 2021$9,386 tax · $29,000 assessed
• 2020$8,994 tax · $29,000 assessed
• 2018$8,797 tax · $29,000 assessed
• 2017$8,632 tax · $29,000 assessed

Home value

$645,000

• Collateral Analytics$645,000
• Cotality$593,700
• Quantarium$689,224

Where it is