About this home

Welcome to 12 Allerton Avenue, a charming ranch-style home in Middletown's established Pilgrim Estates neighborhood, offering the ease of one-level living with the added bonus of a beautifully finished lower level. Step inside to a bright, inviting living room that flows seamlessly into the dining area, creating a comfortable space for everyday living and entertaining. Hardwood floors extend throughout the living and dining areas and all three main-level bedrooms, adding warmth and timeless appeal. The kitchen offers an opportunity to personalize and make it your own, along with a full bathroom that completes the main level. The finished lower level is a standout feature! Recently updated with brand-new tile flooring, this versatile space offers a spacious family room, a beautifully renovated full bathroom with shower, and an additional room ideal for a fourth bedroom, home office, guest space, or hobby room. A dedicated laundry room with utility sink and a new solid wood barn doors add both convenience and character. Step outside and enjoy your own backyard retreat! A composite deck surrounds the above-ground pool, providing the perfect setting for summer gatherings, relaxing weekends, and outdoor entertaining while overlooking the pet friendly fenced-in backyard. We may be turning on the heat now but come summer the central air conditioning will be much appreciated. Enjoy the added benefit of energy-efficient solar panels designed to help reduce monthly electricity costs, with a low lease payment of just $67 per month! The home is also wired for a generator, providing a convenient set up for backup power. Located just minutes from Route 211's shopping and dining corridor, including the Galleria at Crystal Run, Orange Plaza, supermarkets, popular restaurants, and everyday conveniences. Nearby Garnet Health Medical Center and Crystal Run Healthcare provide convenient access to medical services. Enjoy outdoor recreation at Fancher-Davidge Park, Maple Hill Park, and the Orange County Heritage Trail, offering opportunities for walking, biking, and enjoying the outdoors. Downtown Middletown adds local restaurants, shops, and entertainment at the historic Paramount Theatre. Commuter friendly with convenient access to Route 17/I-86 and I-84, along with the nearby Middletown-Town of Wallkill Metro-North station, offering rail connections to Hoboken and New York City via connecting service and Short Line bus service.

Facts and features

Schools

• Maple Hill Elementary School

  elementary · K-5 · 0.8 mi

  3

• Middletown High School

  high · 9-12 · 2.4 mi

  5

• Arc Orange County Chapter

  elementary · K-12 · 0.3 mi

• Monhagen Middle School

  middle · 6-8 · 0.6 mi

  3

• Northern Academy of the Arts

  middle · 6-12 · 0.4 mi

• Fei Tian Academy of the Arts - Site 2

  middle · 6-12 · 0.4 mi

Price history

• Oct 30, 2026 · Listed$398,000
• Aug 5, 2003 · Sold$190,000
• Jul 22, 1992 · Sold$118,500
• Jul 30, 1990 · Sold$127,000

Tax history

• 2026$9,729 tax · $35,600 assessed
• 2025$9,724 tax · $35,600 assessed
• 2024$9,694 tax · $35,600 assessed
• 2023$9,464 tax · $35,600 assessed
• 2022$9,601 tax · $35,600 assessed
• 2021$9,999 tax · $35,600 assessed
• 2020$3,870 tax · $35,600 assessed
• 2017$7,871 tax · $35,600 assessed

Home value

$423,000

• Collateral Analytics$423,000
• Quantarium$407,150
• Cotality$438,000

Where it is