About this home

Arguably, one of the prettiest western facing waterfront settings in Sag Harbor and nestled along the storied Captains Row, Pierson House offers a rare opportunity to own an iconic waterfront residence that blends historic charm with modern possibilities. With 134 feet of private waterfront, a secluded beach, and breathtaking sunset views, this exceptional property embodies the essence of Sag Harbor's maritime heritage. The grand main house features five bedrooms, a formal parlor, an inviting living area, and a screened porch-all exuding timeless character and warmth. A separate one-bedroom guest cottage provides additional privacy and flexibility, perfect for guests or extended family. For those looking to elevate this legacy property, approved plans to expand the main house, add a pool, garage, and waterfront deck, and the potential to create a private dock, a rare and valuable opportunity in this coveted location. Set against the picturesque backdrop of Sag Harbor Cove, this extraordinary home places you in the heart of the village, surrounded by rich history, vibrant culture, and the timeless allure of waterfront living. All just minutes to all that Sag Harbor Village has to offer! Owner will finance.

Facts and features

Schools

• Pierson Middle High School

  middle · 6-12 · 0.6 mi

  8

• Sag Harbor Elementary School

  elementary · K-5 · 0.6 mi

  8

• HARBOR WALDORF SCHOOL

  elementary · PK-K · 0.6 mi

• Ross School

  elementary · K-12 · 3.0 mi

• Ross School

  elementary · PK-12 · 3.5 mi

Price history

• Aug 31, 2026 · Price Changed$7,995,000
• Aug 26, 2026 · Relisted$9,995,000
• Aug 15, 2026 · Listing Removed—
• Aug 25, 2025 · Relisted$9,995,000
• Aug 22, 2025 · Listing Removed—
• Jun 20, 2025 · Price Changed$9,995,000
• Mar 17, 2025 · Relisted$11,900,000
• Feb 7, 2025 · Listing Removed—

Tax history

• 2024$5,354 tax · $1,927,700 assessed
• 2023$15,927 tax · $1,929,500 assessed
• 2022$15,774 tax · $1,929,500 assessed
• 2021$15,626 tax · $1,929,500 assessed
• 2020$10,340 tax · $1,929,500 assessed
• 2018$10,716 tax · $1,865,700 assessed
• 2017$10,714 tax · $1,864,900 assessed
• 2016$11,143 tax · $1,864,900 assessed

Home value

$5,848,000

• Collateral Analytics$5,848,000
• Quantarium$2,811,750

Where it is