About this home

Welcome to 58 Young Avenue, a rare and exceptionally versatile two-family home in Pelham, NY, offering nearly 3,000 square feet of beautifully maintained living space, five bedrooms, three full bathrooms, four fireplaces and outstanding single-family potential. Set in one of Pelham's most desirable residential neighborhoods, this distinctive property combines the space and character of a substantial Pelham home with the flexibility of two thoughtfully configured residences. It is ideally suited to an owner-occupant seeking rental income, an investor searching for a well-maintained Pelham multifamily property, or a buyer interested in multigenerational living or a future single-family conversion. The expansive first-floor residence features three bedrooms and two full bathrooms, along with a sun-filled living room, generously proportioned formal dining room and well-appointed kitchen. Large windows bring abundant natural light into the interiors, while excellent closet and storage options enhance everyday functionality. The second-floor residence is equally inviting, offering two bedrooms, one full bathroom, separate living and dining rooms, and an eat-in kitchen with stainless-steel appliances, including a range and Bosch dishwasher. A large heated sunroom provides valuable additional space for a home office, playroom, den, studio or bonus room. Two eave spaces offer generous walk-in closet space or flexible storage. Existing interior staircases connect the two residences, allowing the home to continue as a true two-family property or function easily for single-family, multigenerational, guest or au pair use. This adaptability makes 58 Young Avenue a particularly compelling opportunity in the Pelham real estate market. The substantial lower level includes a dedicated laundry area with separate washers and dryers for each residence, along with extensive utility and storage space. An integrated one-car garage and driveway parking for three more additional vehicles provide total parking for four cars-an exceptional convenience in a walkable Pelham location. Outdoors, multiple garden patios extend the living space and create a peaceful setting for dining, entertaining or quiet relaxation. Mature landscaping, colorful plantings and private outdoor areas give the property the feel of a secluded retreat while remaining close to everything Pelham has to offer. The home has benefited from significant capital improvements, including modernized electrical and plumbing systems, separate energy-efficient gas-heating systems, an integrated indirect-fired hot-water system, extensive bluestone-to-granite hardscape enhancements, basement waterproofing and repainting, and comprehensive repointing of the hardscape and foundations. Located approximately 0.3 miles from the Pelham Metro-North station and downtown Pelham, 58 Young Avenue offers a highly sought-after walk-to-all lifestyle with convenient access to local schools, shops, restaurants, parks and village amenities. The home is located in the Colonial Elementary School area and offers an approximately 25-minute Metro-North commute to Grand Central. With two spacious residences, nearly 3,000 square feet, five bedrooms, three full baths, abundant storage, private outdoor space, four car parking and remarkable flexibility, 58 Young Avenue stands apart as a truly special Pelham two-family home with single-family potential.

Facts and features

Schools

• Colonial School

  elementary · K-5 · 0.6 mi

  10

• Pelham Middle School

  middle · 6-8 · 0.7 mi

  7

• Pelham Memorial High School

  high · 9-12 · 0.8 mi

  8

• Excelsior Learning Center

  elementary · K · 0.6 mi

• Hutchinson School

  elementary · K-5 · 0.4 mi

  9

• Westchester Area School

  elementary · K-8 · 0.6 mi

Price history

• Sep 24, 2026 · Listed$1,699,000
• Apr 14, 2012 · Listing Removed$2,850
• Feb 2, 2012 · Listed For Rent$2,850
• Nov 3, 2011 · Listing Removed$2,500
• Sep 29, 2011 · Price Changed For Rent$2,500
• Sep 12, 2011 · Price Changed For Rent$2,700
• Jul 26, 2011 · Price Changed For Rent$2,800
• Jun 17, 2011 · Listed For Rent$2,900

Tax history

• 2026$31,667 tax · $1,233,000 assessed
• 2025$31,549 tax · $1,233,000 assessed
• 2024$30,610 tax · $1,186,000 assessed
• 2023$28,963 tax · $1,037,000 assessed
• 2022$29,023 tax · $960,000 assessed
• 2021$28,882 tax · $960,000 assessed
• 2020$26,906 tax · $900,000 assessed
• 2018$34,789 tax · $865,000 assessed

Home value

$1,727,200

• Cotality$1,727,200
• Quantarium$1,734,019
• Collateral Analytics$1,682,000

Where it is