About this home

Prime investment opportunity in the heart of the Village of Suffern! This spacious and well-laid-out colonial offers 5 bedrooms, 2 full bathrooms, and two kitchens, providing excellent flexibility for extended family living or income-producing potential (buyer to verify all permitted uses). Situated on a 7,405 sq ft lot with driveway parking, this property features public water and sewer, natural gas heat, and a spacious backyard ideal for outdoor enjoyment, entertaining, or future enhancements. Upon entry, you are welcomed by a spacious entrance foyer that creates a warm and inviting first impression and leads to a nice patio, perfect for relaxing or hosting guests. The first floor offers a functional layout with a kitchen, full bathroom, and three generously sized bedrooms, providing comfortable living space with excellent flow. The second floor features a separate living area with its own kitchen, full bathroom, and two additional bedrooms, allowing for flexible occupancy arrangements. A full unfinished basement provides ample storage and future potential, subject to approvals. Conveniently located near downtown Suffern, shopping, restaurants, schools, and public transportation, including train and bus service, and located within the desirable Suffern School District. With strong rental demand and a versatile layout, this property is well-suited for investors seeking income potential, value-add opportunities, or owner-occupants looking for space and flexibility. This house was a legal two-family, & might be easy to convert it back, subject to village requirements. It has two separate heating systems, two electrical panels, and two driveways with plenty of parking. Outside, you've got a big, private, flat yard, a detached two-car garage, and an extra shed. Plus, both furnaces and the hot water heater were replaced in 2017. Currently rented out for $4,000 a month

Facts and features

Schools

• Suffern Middle School

  middle · 6-8 · 1.7 mi

  5

• Suffern Senior High School

  high · 9-12 · 2.8 mi

  7

• Sacred Heart School

  elementary · PK-8 · 0.4 mi

• Richard P Connor Elementary School

  elementary · K-2 · 1.0 mi

• Apple Montessorischool of Mahwah

  elementary · PK-K · 1.2 mi

• Congregation Mishknois Lavier

  high · 10-12 · 1.4 mi

Price history

• Aug 6, 2026 · Price Changed$569,000
• Jun 18, 2026 · Listed$599,000
• Apr 29, 2026 · Listing Removed$649,000
• Mar 31, 2026 · Listing Removed$649,000
• Jan 29, 2026 · Listed$649,000
• Feb 1, 2022 · Sold$415,000
• Nov 7, 2021 · Listing Removed—
• Oct 20, 2021 · Listed$399,900

Tax history

• 2026$13,343 tax · $37,600 assessed
• 2025$15,545 tax · $37,600 assessed
• 2024$13,005 tax · $37,600 assessed
• 2023$12,932 tax · $37,600 assessed
• 2022$12,849 tax · $37,600 assessed
• 2021$13,241 tax · $37,600 assessed
• 2020$12,251 tax · $37,600 assessed
• 2018$11,559 tax · $37,600 assessed

Home value

$579,204

• Quantarium$579,204
• Cotality$584,700
• Collateral Analytics$563,000

Where it is