About this home

Welcome to 21 Rustic Road in the heart of Miller Place! Nestled on a beautifully landscaped property, this inviting 5-bedroom, 3-bath Colonial offers 2,519 square feet of living space, combining comfort, charm, and room to spread out. Conveniently located near local shopping, dining, parks, and the North Shore's beautiful beaches, this home offers a wonderful blend of everyday convenience and peaceful surroundings. From the moment you arrive, you'll appreciate the charming curb appeal, spacious driveway, and attached 2-car garage. Step inside to discover bright, welcoming interiors with beautiful hardwood floors, a spacious living room, and a cozy fireplace that adds warmth and character. The beautifully appointed kitchen features white cabinetry, stainless steel appliances, generous counter space, and a center island, flowing seamlessly into the main living areas. Upstairs, you'll find generously sized bedrooms, including a spacious primary bedroom, while the full finished basement offers additional flexible space for recreation, hobbies, or a home office. Head outside to your own backyard retreat, complete with a spacious deck perfect for outdoor dining, entertaining, or simply enjoying the fresh air. The lush lawn, mature trees, and inviting fire pit area create a beautiful setting to unwind and enjoy the outdoors. With its versatile layout, welcoming atmosphere, and desirable Miller Place location, this home has so much to offer. Schedule your private showing today and experience all that 21 Rustic Road has to offer!

Facts and features

Schools

• North Country Road School

  middle · 6-8 · 0.4 mi

  4

• Sound Beach School

  elementary · 3-5 · 0.5 mi

  5

• Miller Place High School

  high · 9-12 · 1.4 mi

  9

• Maryhaven Center Of Hope

  elementary · 3.3 mi

• Andrew Muller Primary School

  elementary · K-2 · 0.7 mi

• Our Lady of Wisdom Regional School

  elementary · PK-8 · 3.5 mi

Price history

• Nov 4, 2026 · Listed$699,000
• Oct 21, 2026 · Listing Removed$699,000
• Jul 2, 2026 · Listed$699,000
• Apr 30, 2025 · Sold$795,000
• Mar 6, 2025 · Sold$775,000
• Jan 7, 2025 · Relisted$799,000
• Jan 3, 2025 · Listing Removed$799,000
• Dec 23, 2024 · Listing Removed$799,000

Tax history

• 2026$18,426 tax · $4,050 assessed
• 2025$18,426 tax · $4,050 assessed
• 2024$17,035 tax · $4,050 assessed
• 2023$16,735 tax · $4,050 assessed
• 2022$16,347 tax · $4,050 assessed
• 2021$15,961 tax · $4,050 assessed
• 2020$14,627 tax · $4,050 assessed
• 2018$14,266 tax · $4,050 assessed

Home value

$711,700

• Cotality$711,700
• Collateral Analytics$692,000
• Quantarium$715,601

Where it is