About this home

Sunset Bay's only duplex is for sale! Walk into instant cash flow since property is completely booked for the Summer 2027 Season! Rare bay-corner 2-unit with oversized boat-ready garage, steps to marina, boat launch, beachfront restaurants and sandy beach. Perfect as a year-round retreat, summer compound or income property in one of Chautauqua County's most popular vacation neighborhoods! Each side is turn key offering 3 furnished bedrooms, spacious living room and large eat-in kitchen. Side A: 1.5 baths. Side B: first-floor bedroom plus 2 full baths. Both units share a large two-level covered back deck that spans the width of the building- ideal for outdoor entertaining or rental guest relaxation. Coin-op washer/dryer, separate electric boxes, hot water tanks and boilers are conveniently located in the common entry. Driveway/off-street parking for each unit and a partially fenced corner lot add privacy and convenience. Exceptional storage space: oversized detached garage approx. 23' x 33' with ~12' clearance from floor to rafters-room for your boat, cars and beach gear. Recent updates include a metal roof on both house and garage and nearly all replacement windows. Sellers can provide carefully screened renter contact information to buyer to help transition rental income; summer weekly rental potential is strong in this market (potential to make 3,000+ per week; buyer to verify). Short walk to marina, state marine park, waterfront dining and all the summer activities that make Sunset Bay a seasonal hotspot. Don't miss this one-of-a-kind opportunity to own the only duplex in Sunset Bay. Ideal for those who want personal waterfront enjoyment plus proven rental demand!

Facts and features

Schools

• Silver Creek Elementary School

  elementary · K-5 · 2.6 mi

  6

• Silver Creek High School

  high · 9-12 · 2.6 mi

  7

• Silver Creek Middle School

  middle · 6-8 · 2.6 mi

  3

Price history

• Oct 27, 2026 · Price Changed$479,900
• May 20, 2026 · Listed$499,900
• Jul 15, 2022 · Sold$320,000
• Dec 15, 2016 · Listing Removed$199,000
• Jun 15, 2016 · Listed$199,000
• Jun 14, 2016 · Listed$199,000
• Oct 2, 2015 · Listing Removed$165,000
• Sep 26, 2015 · Price Changed$165,000

Tax history

• 2026$4,880 tax · $116,000 assessed
• 2025$4,770 tax · $116,000 assessed
• 2024$4,571 tax · $116,000 assessed
• 2023$4,392 tax · $116,000 assessed
• 2022$4,354 tax · $116,000 assessed
• 2021$4,300 tax · $116,000 assessed
• 2017$4,107 tax · $116,000 assessed
• 2016$4,043 tax · $116,000 assessed

Home value

$475,700

• Cotality$475,700
• Collateral Analytics$495,000
• Quantarium$470,584

Where it is