About this home

Welcome to 712 Parsonage Street, a charming Colonial perfectly positioned mid-block in desirable Baldwin Harbor, offering a unique combination of space, versatility, convenience, and proximity to the water. This single-family residence with a legal accessory apartment features 3 bedrooms, 2 full bathrooms, two kitchens, a basement, detached one-car garage, gas cooking, abundant storage, and a spacious backyard-creating an incredible opportunity for today's buyer. Perfect mother daughter! The first floor welcomes you with an open and functional layout featuring one bedroom, two living areas, a kitchen, full bathroom, and an additional office/flex space that offers plenty of possibilities. Whether you need a home office, guest space, playroom, or additional storage, the layout can easily adapt to your lifestyle. Upstairs, the accessory apartment offers even more living space with its own kitchen, two bedrooms, full bathroom, and an impressive oversized living room highlighted by cathedral ceilings. This separate living arrangement provides tremendous flexibility for extended household living or rental income. The rental opportunity can help offset monthly housing expenses, making this home especially attractive for buyers looking to maximize the value of homeownership. The second-floor unit has most recently been marketed as a two-bedroom rental. Outside you'll enjoy a large backyard with plenty of room for entertaining, barbecues, gardening, recreation, or simply relaxing outdoors. The basement, garage, and additional storage throughout the home add even more everyday functionality. Location is another major highlight. Baldwin and Baldwin Harbor provide a true South Shore lifestyle, with direct connections to the area's bays and waterways and numerous parks and recreational opportunities. Nearby favorites include Baldwin Park, offering extensive outdoor recreation, and Silver Lake Park for peaceful outdoor enjoyment. Everyday shopping and conveniences are also close by at Baldwin Harbor Shopping Center, along with restaurants, supermarkets, local shops and services throughout Grand Avenue and Atlantic Avenue. Commuters will appreciate convenient access to the Baldwin LIRR station, located at Sunrise Highway and Grand Avenue. Baldwin is approximately 21 miles east of Manhattan, and the LIRR's Babylon Branch provides direct rail service toward Manhattan, making New York City easily accessible while still enjoying the space and waterfront character of Long Island's South Shore. Whether you're looking for a home with room for extended living, an opportunity to generate rental income to help with the monthly payment, or simply a spacious Colonial close to the water, transportation, shopping and recreation, 712 Parsonage Street has the versatility buyers are looking for. This could be somebody's dream home-and an opportunity to make homeownership work smarter for you.

Facts and features

Schools

• Baldwin Middle School

  middle · 6-8 · 0.6 mi

  5

• Baldwin Senior High School

  high · 9-12 · 2.1 mi

  9

• Steele Elementary School

  elementary · K-5 · 0.3 mi

  10

• Corona Christian Academy

  elementary · K-9 · 0.5 mi

• Meadow Elementary School

  elementary · K-5 · 0.6 mi

  7

• St Christopher Elementary School

  elementary · PK-8 · 1.2 mi

Price history

• Oct 13, 2026 · Listed$819,999
• Nov 13, 2023 · Sold$680,000
• Sep 20, 2023 · Price Changed$680,000
• Aug 29, 2023 · Listed$649,000
• Jun 7, 2022 · Listing Removed$525,000
• Oct 11, 2020 · Listing Removed$525,000
• Nov 1, 2018 · Listing Removed$525,000
• Oct 15, 2018 · Listing Removed$525,000

Tax history

• 2025$14,861 tax · $458 assessed
• 2024$14,125 tax · $458 assessed
• 2022$12,943 tax · $458 assessed
• 2021$17,301 tax · $458 assessed
• 2020$12,230 tax · $445 assessed
• 2019$11,411 tax · $820 assessed
• 2018$10,071 tax · $820 assessed
• 2016$10,594 tax · $820 assessed

Home value

$803,500

• Cotality$803,500
• Quantarium$814,402
• Collateral Analytics$761,000

Where it is