New
$1,549,000
6 bd · 3.5 ba · 3,617 sqft · 0.94 acre lot
75 S Penataquit Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706
Single family · Built 1880 · $428/sqft ·
$9,629/mo est. payment
- Garage
- 2 cars
Flood factor 8/10
About this home
Tax grievance approved : New taxes : $21,071.59 Why settle for the ordinary when extraordinary is within reach? An exceptional home at an exceptional Value. A rare opportunity you won't want to miss. Lovingly restored and thoughtfully enhanced by its current owners, this remarkable 1880 residence reflects years of careful stewardship And substantial investment. Every update was made to elevate everyday living while honoring the home's character and architectural integrity. Updates: 2021 : New Siding & Windows, New PVC & Aluminum Fencing. Leaf Filter on All Gutters 2021/2022 : Basement waterproofed ( Lifetime guarantee ) 2021/2022 : Pool heater & Filter 2022 : New Split Units 2023: Generator, 15 zone Sprinklers, Alarm system with 11 Cameras hooked up to Central Station, Doors 2024: New Kitchen & Appliances, Motorized Shades in Living Room 2025: New driveway, New walkway and Stoops 2026: 2.5 New Bathrooms, with Soaker tub on 2nd floor and wonderful shower on third floor 2026: Newly sealed bricks around pool and back walkway.
Facts and features
Bedrooms
- Bedrooms: 6
- Primary Bedroom Level: Second
- Bedroom 4 Level: Third
- Primary Bedroom Description: Primary Bedroom, Primary Bath, 2 Bedrooms, Full Bath, Office or Bedroom
- Bedroom 4 Description: Two Bedrooms, Full Bath
Other Rooms
- Total Rooms: 10
- Laundry Level: Basement
- Laundry Description: Laundry and Utilities
- Basement Features: Bilco Door(s), Unfinished
- Living Room Level: First
- Living Room Description: Formal Living room with Fireplace,Formal Dining Room with French doors,Den,Custom Kitchen and appliances (2024)
Bathrooms
- Total Bathrooms: 4
- Full Bathrooms: 3
- 1/2 Bathrooms: 1
Interior Features
- Chefs kitchen
- Double vanity
- Eat-in kitchen
- Formal dining
- Kitchen island
- Primary bathroom
- Recessed lighting
- Storage
Appliances
- Dishwasher
- Dryer
- Oven
- Refrigerator
- Stainless steel appliance(s)
- Washer
Heating and Cooling
- Cooling Features: Ductless
- Fireplace Features: Living Room, Wood Burning
- Heating Features: Natural Gas
- Number of Fireplaces: 1
Exterior and Lot Features
- Garden
- Lighting
- Playground
- Rain gutters
- Fencing: Back Yard, Vinyl
- Road Responsibility: Public Maintained Road
Pool and Spa
- Pool Features: In Ground
- Pool Private: Yes
Schools
Brook Avenue Elementary School
elementary · K-2 · 1.0 mi
- 6
Bay Shore Senior High School
high · 9-12 · 1.2 mi
- 5
Bay Shore Middle School
middle · 6-8 · 1.7 mi
St Patrick School
elementary · K-8 · 1.2 mi
- 5
South Country School
elementary · 3-5 · 2.2 mi
BAY SHORE PREKINDERGARTEN CENTER
elementary · K · 0.7 mi
Price history
- Oct 20, 2026 · Relisted$1,549,000
- Oct 15, 2026 · Listing Removed$1,599,000
- Sep 1, 2026 · Listed$1,599,000
- Aug 26, 2026 · Listing Removed$1,699,999
- Aug 13, 2026 · Listed$1,699,999
- May 12, 2021 · Sold$850,000
- Dec 14, 2016 · Sold$699,000
- Nov 1, 2016 · Sold$699,000
Tax history
- 2025$23,094 tax · $68,500 assessed
- 2024$21,346 tax · $68,500 assessed
- 2023$21,346 tax · $68,500 assessed
- 2022$21,323 tax · $68,500 assessed
- 2021$20,721 tax · $68,500 assessed
- 2020$19,832 tax · $68,500 assessed
- 2018$19,362 tax · $68,500 assessed
- 2017$18,724 tax · $67,500 assessed
Home value
$1,531,000
- Cotality$1,531,000
- Quantarium$1,490,185
Where it is
Listed by Maralyn Diggin · Douglas Elliman Central Nassau · OneKeyMLS
