About this home

Some properties are simply for sale...This one is meant to be remembered! Set on five magical pastoral acres along coveted Bellvale Lakes Road, The One Eyed Horse Farm pairs Victorian character, open pasture, wide sky, and true country living, all approximately one hour from New York City in the Warwick Valley Central School District. With rolling grounds, open fields as far as the eye can see, and a barn setup ready for horses, hobby farming, and the animals that make country life feel complete, this is a rare opportunity to live beautifully, breathe deeply, and enjoy Warwick countryside living at its finest. The recent price adjustment reflects the owner obtaining a permit for the approximately 1,500 square feet of finished office space in the barn, adding meaningful value, flexibility, and usability to an already special property. The full barn is approximately 3,000 square feet and was designed for two distinct lifestyles. One side offers stalls, a tack room, and farm functionality for horses, livestock, and barn animals. The other side has been renovated into flexible finished space ideal for a private office or work-from-home setting. It is the kind of space that transforms a beautiful property into something truly exceptional. The residence itself is full of soul, craftsmanship, and presence. Four bedrooms and two and a half baths offer room to spread out, whether as a full-time residence, weekend retreat, gentleman's farm, creative escape, or countryside estate. Inside, soaring ceilings, handcrafted banisters, original wide-plank hardwood floors, period trim, elegant wallpaper, and decorative fireplace mantels carry the romance of a bygone era while still feeling warm, livable, and inviting. The gourmet kitchen is made for gathering, while the formal rooms invite long dinners, holidays, quiet evenings, and lingering conversation. Each bedroom has its own personality and charm, and the primary suite offers a peaceful retreat at the end of the day. Outside, the property is nothing short of magical. Mornings on the covered porch, afternoons in the barn, horses grazing in the pasture, animals settling in for the evening, and nights under open sky remind you why people dream of country life. The land feels private, open, and cinematic, with room to live, work, create, gather, and simply enjoy the beauty around you. And then there is the story. For years, this property belonged to Doc Severinsen, the legendary bandleader from The Tonight Show with Johnny Carson, who is said to have built the shed so he could practice trumpet in peace. That thread of music, creativity, and character still feels woven into the property's spirit. A rare Bellvale Lakes Road offering, approximately one hour from Manhattan yet worlds apart. The One Eyed Horse Farm is more than a home. It is an elegant countryside estate, a turnkey horse farm, a creative retreat, and a magical place designed to be lived in, loved, and remembered.* Showings are by appointment only

Facts and features

Schools

• Warwick Valley Middle School

  elementary · 5-8 · 6.0 mi

  6

• Warwick Valley High School

  high · 9-12 · 6.2 mi

  9

• Bellvale School

  elementary · K-8 · 0.6 mi

• Calvary Christian Academy

  elementary · K-7 · 2.6 mi

• Monroe Day School

  elementary · K-2 · 2.6 mi

• Park Avenue Elementary School

  elementary · K-4 · 4.5 mi

  8

Price history

• Aug 17, 2026 · Price Changed$999,000
• Jul 14, 2026 · Price Changed$945,000
• Jun 27, 2026 · Listed$999,000
• Jun 23, 2026 · Listing Removed$999,995
• May 27, 2026 · Listing Removed$999,995
• May 4, 2026 · Listed$999,995
• May 4, 2026 · Listing Removed$999,995
• Apr 29, 2026 · Listing Removed$1,098,500

Tax history

• 2026$13,990 tax · $59,800 assessed
• 2025$13,955 tax · $59,800 assessed
• 2024$13,735 tax · $59,800 assessed
• 2023$13,481 tax · $59,800 assessed
• 2022$13,324 tax · $59,800 assessed
• 2021$13,443 tax · $59,800 assessed
• 2020$13,398 tax · $59,800 assessed
• 2017$11,772 tax · $59,800 assessed

Home value

$989,000

• Collateral Analytics$989,000
• Cotality$901,100
• Quantarium$990,316

Where it is