About this home

Over 3,000 sq. ft. on 6+ private acres in Hilton, offering the kind of space, privacy, and flexibility that's increasingly hard to find. This 5-bedroom, 2-bath farmhouse combines character with generous living spaces and everyday conveniences. At the heart of the home is an impressive 400+ sq. ft. living room filled with natural light, built-ins, and plenty of room to gather. The spacious primary bedroom stretches from the front to the rear of the home and offers abundant closet space, while four additional bedrooms provide flexibility for family, guests, home offices, or hobbies. An updated kitchen and main bath, first-floor laundry, and a 4-season room overlooking the property add to the home's functionality. Step outside and the property becomes something entirely different. More than 6 acres create a private backdrop filled with wildlife, with your own trails winding through the land for hiking, exploring, and 4-wheeling. Horses are permitted, offering even more possibilities for those dreaming of an equestrian property, hobby farm, or simply having room to spread out and enjoy the outdoors. All of that space comes without giving up convenience. Just minutes from the Village of Hilton, you're close to everyday shopping, dining, and amenities, with Lake Ontario, Braddock Bay Park, Hamlin Beach State Park, and area recreation all within easy reach. If you've been searching for more than just a house-more space, more privacy, and more freedom to make a property your own-1184 West Ave deserves a closer look.

Facts and features

Schools

• Village Elementary School

  elementary · K-6 · 0.4 mi

  4

• Merton Williams Middle School

  middle · 6-8 · 0.5 mi

  4

• Hilton High School

  high · 9-12 · 1.6 mi

  6

• St. Paul Lutheran School

  elementary · K-8 · 1.1 mi

• Quest Elementary School

  elementary · K-6 · 0.5 mi

  8

• Lake Ontario Baptist Academy

  elementary · 2-12 · 2.6 mi

Price history

• Aug 20, 2026 · Listed$499,900
• Jun 30, 2016 · Listing Removed$229,900
• Oct 1, 2015 · Relisted$229,900
• Sep 29, 2015 · Listing Removed$229,900
• May 5, 2015 · Listed$229,900
• Oct 16, 2012 · Listing Removed$249,900
• Jun 29, 2012 · Listed$249,900
• Dec 22, 2011 · Listing Removed$229,900

Tax history

• 2026$6,237 tax · $323,700 assessed
• 2025$6,198 tax · $323,700 assessed
• 2024$4,582 tax · $323,700 assessed
• 2023$6,350 tax · $215,500 assessed
• 2022$6,452 tax · $215,500 assessed
• 2021$7,877 tax · $215,500 assessed
• 2020$6,243 tax · $215,500 assessed
• 2017$6,199 tax · $215,500 assessed

Home value

$495,000

• Collateral Analytics$495,000
• Cotality$505,200
• Quantarium$485,868

Where it is