About this home

Welcome to 205 High Street in the heart of Monroe, where timeless craftsmanship meets modern comfort in this truly one-of-a-kind Colonial located within the highly sought-after Monroe-Woodbury School District. Situated on a beautiful corner lot, this exceptional property offers a rare opportunity to purchase separately or together with the neighboring custom-built home at 23 Sweezy Place, originally designed to complement the home while providing additional living space and an impressive four-car garage. From the moment you arrive, the slate roof, covered rocking-chair front porch, side porch, and stunning woodwork and quarter-sawn tiger oak flooring set the tone for the home's warm, old-world charm. Inside, the custom gourmet kitchen is a chef's dream, featuring handcrafted pantry cabinetry, wood beams, a farmhouse sink, oversized island with storage, subway tile backsplash, wide plank aged flooring, spice racks, refuse drawer, custom-paneled refrigerator, breakfast nook, and a Viking dual-fuel range with four burners, grill, and double ovens. Entertain with ease in the formal dining room, inviting living room with a slate wood-burning fireplace, and the spectacular sunroom/mudroom showcasing custom stained glass and built-in cabinetry. The luxurious primary suite offers his-and-her closets, a private sitting sunroom filled with natural light. The bathroom has a spa-inspired marble bath complete with a soaking tub, oversized shower with five shower heads, porcelain vanity, and a custom six-foot medicine cabinet. Two additional bedrooms and beautiful oak doors throughout complete the second floor. Step outside to your own private resort featuring a heated gunite pool with hot tub, paver patio, outdoor kitchen with a Viking natural gas BBQ with 2 burners, outdoor shower with tankless water heater, fully fenced yard, and multiple patios spaces offer space for everyone. A wood-burning fireplace creates the perfect setting for relaxing poolside on cool evenings. The full basement provides endless possibilities, recreation space, or storage. Walk to the Village, located just moments from Mill Pond, charming village shops, restaurants, farmers markets, wineries, parks, and recreational amenities, this commuter-friendly location is approximately 50 miles from NYC and offers easy access to Routes 17, 84, and 87, Metro-North, NJ Transit, bus service, Stewart International Airport, and West Point. A truly rare offering combining character, luxury, and versatility-schedule your private showing today and don't forget to inquire about the neighboring property at 23 Sweezy Place.

Facts and features

Schools

• Monroe Woodbury Middle School

  middle · 6-8 · 3.0 mi

  5

• Monroe Woodbury High School

  high · 9-12 · 3.1 mi

  6

• Bnai Yoel School

  elementary · K · 0.2 mi

• Cong Bnai Yoel

  elementary · K-12 · 0.2 mi

• United Talmudical Academy Of Kiryas Joel

  elementary · K-12 · 0.2 mi

• Bais Rochel School

  elementary · PK-12 · 0.2 mi

Price history

• Oct 28, 2026 · Listed$660,000
• Oct 18, 2026 · Listing Removed$669,900
• Oct 1, 2026 · Price Changed$669,900
• Aug 8, 2026 · Price Changed$694,900
• Jun 19, 2026 · Listed$699,000
• Oct 27, 1999 · Sold$276,000

Tax history

• 2026$14,615 tax · $59,600 assessed
• 2025$14,449 tax · $59,600 assessed
• 2024$14,143 tax · $59,600 assessed
• 2023$13,888 tax · $59,600 assessed
• 2022$13,618 tax · $59,600 assessed
• 2021$13,625 tax · $59,600 assessed
• 2020$13,398 tax · $59,600 assessed
• 2017$12,948 tax · $59,600 assessed

Home value

$680,800

• Cotality$680,800
• Collateral Analytics$688,000
• Quantarium$654,655

Where it is