About this home

Offered to the market for the first time in more than 25 years, homes with this level of original character, and preservation are increasingly hard to come by. From the moment you arrive, this home makes an impression which is sure to please. Watch the neighborhood go by from the beautiful mahogany front porch before stepping through the entry vestibule, where pristine original tiles immediately sets the tone. Inside, you're captivated by original wainscoting, ornate staircase spindles, soaring 10 foot ceilings and period details that have been carefully preserved and restored throughout. The formal living room showcases original plaster detailing, elegant wall sconces, engineered hardwood flooring, and an abundance of natural light through double-pane replacement windows. Enter through pocket doors to the spacious formal dining room comfortably accommodating a table for 8 and is anchored by an original fireplace, creating a dramatic focal point for dinners and entertaining. At the heart of the home is a renovated kitchen designed to complement the property's historic character while providing the functionality expected today. The open concept layout features a large center island and a breakfast bar with room for 4. 3 bathrooms add tremendous convenience. The restored primary bathroom is a standout, featuring a classic clawfoot tub and Restoration Hardware-style trim and fixtures, perfectly blending old world charm with modern luxury. Upstairs, the king size primary suite is filled with natural light and offers a large closet along with a dedicated seating area. The secondary bedrooms are generously sized and comfortably accommodate queen size beds. Continue upward to the massive attic, an incredibly versatile space with the potential to serve as a fourth bedroom, home office, studio, playroom, or private hangout. The full basement provides even more usable space with exterior access, a full bathroom, family room, storage room, and utility area. Outside, enjoy a large rear deck overlooking the backyard and above ground pool. A private garage and driveway provide off street parking for multiple vehicles an invaluable feature in this neighborhood. The location ties it all together. Just moments from Forest Avenue, you will experience the neighborhood bakeries, restaurants, nightlife, shopping, and public transportation. With convenient access to major routes and bridges, commuting off Staten Island is equally effortless. 443 Bement Avenue is more than a home it is a pillar of Staten Island history meticulously restored for its next chapter. Modern where it matters, original where it counts, and unlike almost anything else on the market. Dont pass up this once is a 25 year opportunity.

Facts and features

Schools

• Ps 45 John Tyler

  elementary · K-5 · 0.3 mi

  7

• Is 61 William A Morris

  middle · 6-8 · 0.8 mi

  2

• Curtis High School

  high · 9-12 · 1.8 mi

  4

• Sacred Heart School

  elementary · PK-8 · 0.2 mi

• Is 27 Anning S Prall

  middle · 6-8 · 0.4 mi

  5

• Yeshiva Tifereth Torah

  high · 9-12 · 0.5 mi

Price history

• Oct 8, 2026 · Listed$899,999
• Nov 25, 2016 · Sold$499,500
• Aug 15, 1997 · Sold$167,000

Tax history

• 2025$7,028 tax · $48,480 assessed
• 2024$7,028 tax · $47,280 assessed
• 2023$6,825 tax · $48,300 assessed
• 2022$6,540 tax · $40,560 assessed
• 2021$6,505 tax · $33,600 assessed
• 2020$6,172 tax · $33,180 assessed
• 2019$6,225 tax · $32,220 assessed
• 2018$5,858 tax · $28,008 assessed

Home value

$769,600

• Cotality$769,600
• Quantarium$884,321
• Collateral Analytics$668,000

Where it is