New
$599,000
3 bd · 1.5 ba · 1,874 sqft · 0.61 acre lot
21 Elm Pl, Milltown, NJ 08850
Single family · Built 1938 · $320/sqft ·
$4,218/mo est. payment
- Garage
- 1 car
- Stories
- 2
3D tourFlood factor 1/10
About this home
Step into the timeless charm of this one-of-a-kind custom-built 1923 Colonial, offering classic character and endless potential. The first floor features a welcoming living room with a fireplace, a cozy sitting room, formal dining room, spacious eat-in country kitchen, convenient powder room, and a screened-in porch perfect for relaxing and enjoying the peaceful surroundings. The second floor offers three generously sized bedrooms, two of which feature their own private sitting rooms, providing flexible space for a home office, reading nook, or nursery. Stairs access to the expansive attic presents an excellent opportunity to create a luxurious primary suite, guest quarters, or additional living space. A picturesque backyard that gently slopes to Farrington Lake, where you can launch your canoe or kayak and enjoy waterfront living right from your own property. Ideally located near major highways, NJ Transit, bus lines, and Newark Liberty International Airport, this home also offers easy access to downtown New Brunswick's acclaimed restaurants, theaters, and entertainment. Minutes from Rutgers University, Robert Wood Johnson University Hospital, and Saint Peter's University Hospital, all while enjoying the charm and close-knit community of desirable Milltown. A truly special property combining historic character, scenic beauty, and an unbeatable location.
Facts and features
Bedrooms
- Bedrooms: 3
- Primary Bedroom Features: Sitting Area
Other Rooms
- Total Rooms: 11
- Basement Description: Full, Exterior Entry, Storage Space, Laundry Facilities
Bathrooms
- Total Bathrooms: 1.5
- Full Bathrooms: 1
- 1/2 Bathrooms: 1
Interior Features
- Cedar closet(s)
- Entrance foyer
- Kitchen
- Bath half
- Living room
- Other room(s)
- Dining room
- 3 bedrooms
Appliances
- Dishwasher
- Dryer
- Gas range/oven
- Refrigerator
- Range
- Washer
- Gas water heater
- Laundry Features: In Basement
Heating and Cooling
- Cooling Features: Wall Unit(s), Window Unit(s)
- Fireplace Features: Wood Burning
- Heating Features: Radiant, Radiators-Hot Water
- Heating: Yes
- Number of Fireplaces: 1
Kitchen and Dining
- Dining Room Features: Formal Dining Room
- Kitchen Features: Country Kitchen,Eat-in Kitchen
Exterior and Lot Features
- Barbecue
- Patio
- Enclosed porch(es)
- Sidewalk
- Fencing/wall
- Yard
- Fencing: Fencing/Wall
- Patio And Porch Features: Patio, Enclosed
Schools
- 5
Joyce Kilmer Elementary School
elementary · 4-8 · 0.2 mi
Cheder Menachem
elementary · K-7 · 0.2 mi
Nuview Academy
elementary · K-12 · 2.1 mi
- 7
Parkview Elementary School
elementary · K-3 · 0.6 mi
Our Lady of Lourdes School
elementary · K-8 · 0.3 mi
Unitarian Montessori School
elementary · PK-K · 1.1 mi
Price history
- Sep 28, 2026 · Price Changed$599,000
- Sep 11, 2026 · Price Changed$624,000
- Aug 10, 2026 · Price Changed$649,000
- Jul 27, 2026 · Price Changed$674,000
- Jul 16, 2026 · Price Changed$699,000
- Jul 15, 2026 · Listed$649,900
- Mar 21, 2017 · Sold$360,000
- Jan 17, 2017 · Listing Removed$359,900
Tax history
- 2025$14,075 tax · $202,500 assessed
- 2024$13,676 tax · $202,500 assessed
- 2023$13,427 tax · $202,500 assessed
- 2022$13,367 tax · $202,500 assessed
- 2021$13,089 tax · $202,500 assessed
- 2020$12,773 tax · $202,500 assessed
- 2019$12,275 tax · $202,500 assessed
- 2018$11,548 tax · $202,500 assessed
Home value
$611,149
- Quantarium$611,149
- Collateral Analytics$742,000
- Cotality$606,500
Where it is
Listed by Eileen Thomas · RE/MAX Country · AllJerseyMLS
