About this home

Tucked into the trees overlooking Kingsmill Pond, 17 Whittakers Mill feels more like a private resort retreat than a home in the heart of Williamsburg. With approximately 4,500 square feet, 5 bedrooms and 4 full baths, this one-of-a-kind home was designed to embrace its wooded waterfront setting. Soaring ceilings, warm wood floors and finishes, walls of windows, and a dramatic brick fireplace give the main living spaces the character of a mountain lodge, while an interior atrium fills the center of the home with natural light. The spacious primary suite is a retreat of its own, and multiple living and gathering spaces provide plenty of room to spread out. Outside, an expansive deck stretches across the rear of the home overlooking the trees and water, with steps leading down to a private dock and boat lift on Kingsmill Pond. All of this is located within Kingsmill, one of Williamsburg's most established gated communities, with 24-hour security and HOA amenities that include multiple pools, tennis courts, basketball courts, playgrounds and more. Additional membership opportunities are available through Kingsmill Club, offering three golf courses, tennis, fitness facilities, indoor and outdoor pools, a lazy river and additional resort amenities. A truly unique home and setting that feels worlds away while still being right in Williamsburg.

Facts and features

Schools

• James River Elementary School

  elementary · K-5 · 3.5 mi

  4

• Berkeley Middle School

  middle · 6-8 · 4.5 mi

  7

• Jamestown High School

  high · 9-12 · 6.6 mi

  6

• Gilead Christian Academy

  elementary · K-3 · 2.7 mi

• Matthew Whaley Elementary School

  elementary · K-5 · 3.1 mi

  5

• Walsingham Academy Lower School

  elementary · K-7 · 3.3 mi

Price history

• Oct 29, 2026 · Price Changed$999,999
• Oct 29, 2026 · Price Changed$999,999
• Sep 25, 2026 · Listed$1,100,000
• Sep 22, 2026 · Listed$1,100,000
• Jan 1, 2001 · Sold$668,100
• Jan 1, 1997 · Sold$524,000

Tax history

• 2026$7,080 tax · $907,700 assessed
• 2025$6,727 tax · $907,700 assessed
• 2024$6,321 tax · $810,500 assessed
• 2023$6,060 tax · $730,200 assessed
• 2022$6,060 tax · $730,200 assessed
• 2021$5,961 tax · $709,700 assessed
• 2020$5,961 tax · $709,700 assessed
• 2019$5,961 tax · $709,700 assessed

Home value

$1,059,500

• Cotality$1,059,500
• Quantarium$1,045,839
• Collateral Analytics$1,089,000

Where it is