New construction
$1,375,000
9 bd · 4.5 ba · 4,450 sqft · 8,712 sqft lot
96 Hillside Ave, Nutley, NJ 07110
Multi-family · Built 1900 · $309/sqft ·
$8,757/mo est. payment
Flood factor 1/10
About this home
PREMIER NUTLEY 4-FAMILY " Hillside Avenue Corridor, 50% Vacancy as of 07/01/268- Car Parking & Duplex Setup! Trophy investment opportunity on historic Hillside Avenue. This legal 4-unit Victorian sits on a quiet, tree-lined residential block just 12 miles from Midtown Manhattan. Perfect for an owner-occupant or value-add investor seeking immediate upside. The property is delivered with TWO UNITS VACANT, creating a cash-flow opportunity from Day 1. Units 1 & 3(Occupied), providing stable income. Unit 2(Vacant as of 07/01/26) Recently renovated (2024) Unit 4 (Vacant Duplex): Large two-story duplex, 1600 sq ft, with loft space, ready for renovation and significant rental upside or owner use. PRIVATE 8-CAR PARKING LOT: Rare for the Hillside Avenue corridor. Three spaces are currently rented to neighborhood residents. These spaces offer additional income potential or future tenant amenities. Separate utilities for all units. Passed all state and local inspections. Newly upgraded and updated 200 amp electrical service and panels.
Facts and features
Bedrooms
- Bedrooms: 9
Other Rooms
- Total Rooms: 22
- Basement Description: Full
Bathrooms
- Total Bathrooms: 4.10
- Full Bathrooms: 4
- 1/2 Bathrooms: 1
Interior Features
- Carbon monoxide detector
- Fire alarm sys
- Fire extinguisher
- High ceilings
- Smoke detector
- Tile floors
- Vinyl-linoleum floors
Heating and Cooling
- Cooling Features: 4 Units, Window A/C(s)
- Heating Features: Forced Hot Air, Radiators - Hot Water
- Heating Fuel: Gas-Natural
- Heating: Yes
Exterior and Lot Features
- Curbs
- Enclosed porch(es)
- Metal fence
- Partially fenced
- Patio
- Sidewalk
- Storm window(s)
- Patio: Yes
Garage and Parking
- Driveway: 1 Car Width, Assigned, Blacktop, Fencing, Off-Street Parking, Parking Lot-Exclusive
- Parking Total: 8
Land Info
- Lot Size Acres: 0.2
- Lot Size Dimensions: 50X173
- Lot Size Square Feet: 8712
Schools
- 6
John H Walker Middle School
middle · 7-8 · 0.3 mi
- 5
Nutley High School
high · 9-12 · 0.4 mi
- 9
Yantacaw Elementary School
elementary · K-6 · 0.4 mi
Good Shepherd Academy
elementary · PK-8 · 0.9 mi
- 8
Radcliffe Elementary School
elementary · K-6 · 0.5 mi
- 7
Spring Garden Elementary School
elementary · K-6 · 0.5 mi
Price history
- Jul 27, 2026 · Price Changed$1,375,000
- Jun 3, 2026 · Listed$1,435,000
- Mar 22, 2014 · Listing Removed$595,000
- Mar 21, 2014 · Listing Removed$595,000
- Aug 21, 2013 · Listed$595,000
- Aug 21, 2013 · Listed$595,000
- Aug 20, 2013 · Listing Removed$595,000
- Aug 18, 2013 · Listing Removed$595,000
Tax history
- 2025$21,214 tax · $786,000 assessed
- 2024$20,687 tax · $786,000 assessed
- 2023$20,247 tax · $786,000 assessed
- 2022$20,332 tax · $526,200 assessed
- 2021$20,227 tax · $526,200 assessed
- 2020$19,374 tax · $526,200 assessed
- 2019$18,985 tax · $526,200 assessed
- 2018$18,474 tax · $526,200 assessed
Home value
$1,354,168
- Quantarium$1,354,168
- Cotality$1,347,300
- Collateral Analytics$1,361,000
Where it is
Listed by Ronnie Glomb · YOUR TOWN REALTY · GardenState
