About this home

Bright, cheerful and full of endless possibility, 9 McCarter Ave is an inviting place to begin your next chapter in Fair Haven. Set on a 50 x 150 lot, this two-bedroom home offers a welcoming atmosphere and the opportunity to enjoy it as it is, renovate to suit your style or explore building your dream home. Its sunny feel brings warmth to everyday living, while the backyard offers space to relax, garden and gather with friends. Picture bike rides around town and embracing the community spirit that makes Fair Haven so special. Whether you love the home's personality or envision a fresh start, this is your chance to put down roots and create a home that reflects your vision. Discover the charm today and imagine tomorrow. Renovation and new construction are subject to municipal approvals.

Facts and features

Schools

• Viola L. Sickles Elementary School

  elementary · K-3 · 0.4 mi

  10

• Knollwood Elementary School

  elementary · 4-8 · 0.6 mi

  8

• Rumson Fair Haven Regional High School

  high · 9-12 · 1.7 mi

  10

• The Jayne S. Carmody School at RCDS

  elementary · K-8 · 1.0 mi

• Tower Hill School

  elementary · PK-K · 1.5 mi

• Red Bank Catholic High School

  high · 9-12 · 2.0 mi

Price history

• Oct 8, 2026 · Listed$999,000
• Feb 14, 2019 · Listing Removed—
• Nov 26, 2018 · Price Changed$509,999
• Oct 15, 2018 · Price Changed$519,999
• Oct 1, 2018 · Price Changed$531,999
• Sep 3, 2018 · Price Changed$550,000
• Aug 13, 2018 · Listed$575,000
• Oct 18, 2009 · Listing Removed$425,000

Tax history

• 2025$10,855 tax · $879,000 assessed
• 2024$9,815 tax · $760,700 assessed
• 2023$9,362 tax · $594,800 assessed
• 2022$9,066 tax · $530,800 assessed
• 2021$8,312 tax · $448,100 assessed
• 2020$7,712 tax · $418,500 assessed
• 2019$7,601 tax · $416,500 assessed
• 2018$7,658 tax · $411,100 assessed

Home value

$967,000

• Collateral Analytics$967,000
• Quantarium$1,001,768
• Cotality$743,200

Where it is