About this home

Seller Is Accepting Back Up Offers! Welcome to 35257 Cats Point Lane, a truly distinctive waterfront property situated on 7 acres along the Machipongo River. Built in 1984 and offering approximately 2,860 square feet of living space, this home combines generous proportions, beautiful water views, and architectural details inspired by centuries past. The right wing was thoughtfully designed to replicate the character of traditional homes built on the Eastern Shore during the late 1700s and 1800s, incorporating reclaimed wood flooring, trim, wall panels, doors, hinges, mantels, and other period elements that give the home a warmth and authenticity rarely found in newer construction. The main level offers a spacious and functional layout featuring a family room, formal living room, kitchen, dining room, breakfast nook, half bath, and primary suite. Multiple decks overlook the Machipongo River, creating inviting spaces to relax, entertain, and enjoy the peaceful waterfront setting. Upstairs, you'll find four additional bedrooms, a full bathroom, and attic storage. The walkout ground level adds tremendous versatility with two garage bays and an abundance of additional space ideal for a recreation room, workshop, hobby area, storage, or a combination of uses. With 5 bedrooms, 2.5 bathrooms, expansive waterfront acreage, and a setting rich in Eastern Shore character, this property offers a unique opportunity for those seeking privacy, space, and direct connection to the water. Please note: the existing septic system is designed for a 3-bedroom capacity.

Facts and features

Schools

• Pungoteague Elementary School

  elementary · K-5 · 6.9 mi

  5

• Nandua High School

  high · 9-12 · 8.2 mi

  4

• Nandua Middle School

  middle · 6-8 · 8.4 mi

  6

• Shore Christian Academy

  elementary · K-8 · 4.8 mi

• Badger Technical Center - South

  elementary · 8.2 mi

• Accawmacke Elementary School

  elementary · K-5 · 9.2 mi

  3

Price history

• Sep 26, 2026 · Price Changed$406,453
• Sep 22, 2026 · Price Changed$406,453
• Sep 14, 2026 · Price Changed$419,024
• Sep 14, 2026 · Price Changed$419,024
• Sep 9, 2026 · Listing Removed—
• Sep 8, 2026 · Listed$431,938
• Sep 8, 2026 · Listed$431,983
• Jul 28, 2026 · Price Changed$499,999

Tax history

• 2026$2,606 tax · $536,400 assessed
• 2025$2,158 tax · $404,300 assessed
• 2023$1,958 tax · $329,200 assessed
• 2022$1,958 tax · $329,200 assessed
• 2021$1,992 tax · $326,600 assessed
• 2020$1,992 tax · $326,600 assessed
• 2019$1,920 tax · $314,800 assessed
• 2018$1,920 tax · $314,800 assessed

Home value

$406,890

• Quantarium$406,890

Where it is