New
3D tour
$540,000
5 bd · 2 ba · 2,010 sqft · 0.70 acre lot
58 Middle Haddam Rd, East Hampton, CT 06456
Single family · Built 1780 · $269/sqft ·
$3,314/mo est. payment
- Garage
- 2 cars
3D tourFlood factor 4/10
About this home
HISTORIC NEW ENGLAND CHARM- TWO HOURS FROM MANHATTAN AND BOSTON. A historic home with a waterfall, saltwater pool, mature gardens and brook, nestled among old-growth oak and maple. Tucked into the Connecticut River Valley, this beautifully restored 18th-century house offers an authentic country retreat within easy reach of both cities. Listed on the National Register of Historic Places and set on almost an acre, the home combines original character with thoughtful modern updates, including a remotely operated irrigation system. Five bedrooms provide plenty of room for family and friends, while single-level living adds ease and flexibility. Enjoy morning coffee by the brook, lazy summer afternoons beside the pool, autumn evenings by the fire and holidays gathered together in the country. Just a three-minute walk from the Connecticut River, the property is close to a launching slip, charming river towns, hiking, restaurants and wineries. Metro-North and Amtrak connections provide additional travel options from New York. The property also has a successful, established short-term rental history, offering the flexibility to generate income when not in personal use. Whether envisioned as a weekend escape, full-time country home or distinctive property with established income potential, the Captain Elijah Johnson House is a rare opportunity to enjoy the timeless pleasures of New England country living. *Recent upgrades include: irrigation system, tesla charger, new septic, thermal insulation, electric heat pump water heater, new well tank and pump, chimney liner for 2 working fireplaces, saltwater Gunite pool, 2 updated bathrooms, kitchen renovation, Lacanche oven/range, electrical, new windows, repainted exterior. Full list with dollar amounts in dropdown.**
Facts and features
Bedrooms
- Bedrooms: 5
- Primary Bedroom Dimensions: 15' x 12'
- Bedroom 1 Dimensions: 13' x 12'
- Bedroom 2 Dimensions: 11' x 12'
- Bedroom 3 Dimensions: 12' x 12'
- Bedroom 4 Dimensions: 12' x 10'
- Primary Bedroom Level: Main
- Bedroom 1 Level: Upper
Other Rooms
- Total Rooms: 7
- Basement Features: Full, Unfinished, Full With Walk-Out
- Office: Yes
- Family Room Dimensions: 15' x 12'
- Office/Study Room Dimensions: 13' x 13'
- Family Room Level: Main
- Office/Study Room Level: Main
- Family Room Features: Beams, Fireplace, Hardwood Floor
Bathrooms
- Total Bathrooms: 2
- Full Bathrooms: 2
Appliances
- Oven/range
- Refrigerator
- Washer
- Dryer
- Laundry Features: Upper Level
Heating and Cooling
- Cooling Features: Window Unit
- Heating Features: Hot Air
- Heating Fuel: Electric,Oil
- Heating: Yes
- Number of Fireplaces: 2
- Water Heaters: Oil, Domestic
Kitchen and Dining
- Dining Room Dimensions: 21' x 10'
- Dining Room Features: Hardwood Floor
- Dining Room Level: Main
Exterior and Lot Features
- Stone wall,underground sprinkler,patio
- Patio: Yes
Pool and Spa
- Pool Features: Gunite,Heated,Salt Water,In Ground Pool
Schools
- 7
East Hampton Middle School
middle · 6-8 · 1.7 mi
- 8
East Hampton High School
high · 9-12 · 2.7 mi
- 7
Center School
elementary · 4-5 · 2.9 mi
Xavier High School
high · 9-12 · 3.9 mi
- 8
Memorial School
elementary · K-3 · 3.5 mi
The Learning Center At East Hampton
high · 9-12 · 2.9 mi
Price history
- Sep 3, 2026 · Price Changed$540,000
- Jun 18, 2026 · Price Changed$599,000
- May 4, 2026 · Price Changed$629,000
- Mar 13, 2026 · Price Changed$659,000
- Nov 14, 2025 · Listed$689,000
- Nov 5, 2025 · Listing Removed—
- Jun 17, 2025 · Price Changed$699,000
- Apr 5, 2025 · Listed$745,000
Tax history
- 2026$6,836 tax · $245,980 assessed
- 2025$6,560 tax · $165,190 assessed
- 2023$5,957 tax · $165,190 assessed
- 2022$5,725 tax · $165,190 assessed
- 2021$5,704 tax · $165,190 assessed
- 2020$5,566 tax · $167,950 assessed
- 2019$5,321 tax · $160,550 assessed
- 2018$5,028 tax · $160,550 assessed
Home value
$535,000
- Collateral Analytics$535,000
- Quantarium$389,184
- Cotality$569,800
Where it is
Listed by Teri Lewis · William Pitt Sotheby's International Realty · SMARTMLS
