About this home

Welcome to 131 Keating Street, a custom two-family Colonial tucked away on a private cul-de-sac in highly sought-after Princes Bay. Set on an oversized property in a serene setting, this well-maintained home offers approximately 3,260 sq ft of living space, not including the full basement, with impressive scale and flexibility. The main residence features four bedrooms, three bathrooms, gleaming hardwood floors, kitchen with a walk in pantry and a spacious family room with fireplace. The primary bedroom includes a private bathroom and ample closet space. The second-floor one-bedroom apartment offers a private entrance, full kitchen, living room, full bathroom, and bedroom. Additional highlights include a built-in garage, full basement with tremendous storage, generous deck space, and an expansive backyard oasis. A unique opportunity to own a substantial two-family detached home on an exceptional property in Princes Bay.

Facts and features

Schools

• Ps 3 The Margaret Gioiosa School

  elementary · K-5 · 0.7 mi

  8

• Is 7 Elias Bernstein

  middle · 6-8 · 0.7 mi

  9

• Tottenville High School

  high · 9-12 · 0.8 mi

  7

• Ss Joseph & Thomas School

  elementary · PK-8 · 0.9 mi

• Ps 5 Huguenot

  elementary · K-5 · 1.0 mi

  9

• Yeshiva Of Staten Island

  high · 9-12 · 1.1 mi

Price history

• Sep 30, 2026 · Listed$1,425,000
• Jul 20, 1993 · Sold$295,000
• Sep 14, 1992 · Sold$62,500
• Jul 18, 1990 · Sold$50,000

Tax history

• 2025$13,044 tax · $65,340 assessed
• 2024$12,290 tax · $66,840 assessed
• 2023$11,696 tax · $67,200 assessed
• 2022$10,823 tax · $65,220 assessed
• 2021$11,416 tax · $60,840 assessed
• 2020$11,396 tax · $57,480 assessed
• 2019$10,608 tax · $58,560 assessed
• 2018$9,978 tax · $49,162 assessed

Home value

$1,402,484

• Quantarium$1,402,484
• Collateral Analytics$1,592,000
• Cotality$1,372,800

Where it is