About this home

Welcome to 39 Pitney Ave, a beautifully maintained, detached legal two-family home in the heart of Pleasant Plains! This spacious side-hall Colonial offers three bedrooms and three bathrooms in the main residence, plus a separate one-bedroom, one-bathroom apartment. Combining comfort, style, and versatility, this home offers an exceptional opportunity for homeowners and investors alike. Recent updates include a renovated kitchen, updated flooring, windows, roof, garage door, two-zone baseboard heating, and a new pool liner. Enter through the steel entry doors into a welcoming living room featuring hardwood floors and a charming balcony overlooking the front yard. This level also offers a convenient half bath and a dedicated laundry room. The spacious, renovated eat-in kitchen is truly the heart of the home, showcasing stainless steel appliances, quartz countertops, an oversized island, and abundant cabinetry and pantry storage. Sliding glass doors lead to a large deck overlooking the backyard, complete with an above-ground pool-perfect for entertaining, relaxing, and enjoying the warmer months. Upstairs, you'll find three bedrooms and a full bathroom. The primary suite features a spacious walk-in closet and a beautifully renovated private three-quarter bathroom, creating a comfortable retreat at the end of the day. Adding exceptional value and flexibility, the property features a separate, legal one-bedroom apartment with its own utilities and a full bathroom. Whether you're looking for additional living space for extended family or the opportunity for rental income, this versatile property offers wonderful possibilities.

Facts and features

Schools

• Ps 3 The Margaret Gioiosa School

  elementary · K-5 · 0.8 mi

  8

• Tottenville High School

  high · 9-12 · 1.4 mi

  7

• Is 34 Tottenville

  middle · 6-8 · 2.0 mi

  9

• Yeshiva Of Staten Island

  high · 9-12 · 0.3 mi

• Kathleen Grimm School For Leadership

  elementary · K-5 · 0.8 mi

  8

• Ss Joseph & Thomas School

  elementary · PK-8 · 0.5 mi

Price history

• Oct 28, 2026 · Listed$1,199,000
• Jan 14, 2003 · Sold$482,000

Tax history

• 2025$9,940 tax · $62,340 assessed
• 2024$9,625 tax · $54,660 assessed
• 2023$9,154 tax · $62,100 assessed
• 2022$8,466 tax · $51,000 assessed
• 2021$8,618 tax · $42,360 assessed
• 2020$8,903 tax · $46,800 assessed
• 2019$8,295 tax · $46,020 assessed
• 2018$7,796 tax · $38,732 assessed

Home value

$1,032,000

• Collateral Analytics$1,032,000
• Quantarium$915,622
• Cotality$1,099,300

Where it is