About this home

A HISTORIC FARMHOUSE. A MODERN SENSIBILITY. Some houses simply have a sense of place. This 1905 Sag Harbor farmhouse is one of them. Set on approximately .34 acre in the heart of Sag Harbor Village, this charming two-story home blends the character of another era with the openness and ease of modern living. Renovated in 2023, the home is filled with natural light and an airy, relaxed atmosphere that feels equally suited to quiet mornings, long summer afternoons and evenings spent entertaining friends. the open kitchen with granite countertops connects naturally to the living spaces, while hardwood floors, a separate dining room, living room family room and freestanding fireplace preserve the warmth and personality of the original farmhouse. Three bedrooms and 2.5 baths provide comfortable spaces for family and guests. Outside, the property unfolds into its own private village retreat, with a welcoming fenced in courtyard, rear deck, outdoor shower and room for a pool. A detached shed can be expanded as a studio / pool house. Or use for practical storage. For those who envision something more, architectural plans are included for an expansion that would approximately double the existing size of the house - offering the opportunity to create an even more substantial Sag Harbor home while retaining the original spirit. Then there is the village itself. From this location, Main Street, restaurants, shops, the waterfront and boating are all approximately a 10-minute stroll away. Leave the car behind and wander into the heart of Sag Harbor, where village life, maritime history and the energy of the Hampton's come together.

Facts and features

Schools

• Pierson Middle High School

  middle · 6-12 · 0.1 mi

  8

• Sag Harbor Elementary School

  elementary · K-5 · 0.3 mi

  8

• HARBOR WALDORF SCHOOL

  elementary · PK-K · 0.8 mi

• Ross School

  elementary · PK-12 · 3.0 mi

• Ross School

  elementary · K-12 · 3.1 mi

Price history

• Oct 17, 2026 · Price Changed For Rent—
• Oct 3, 2026 · Listed$3,950,000
• Aug 14, 2026 · Listed For Rent$11,666
• May 17, 2024 · Listing Removed—
• Jan 3, 2024 · Price Changed For Rent$10,416
• Dec 21, 2023 · Listed For Rent$10,000
• Oct 19, 2023 · Listing Removed—
• Jan 30, 2023 · Listed For Rent$75,000

Tax history

• 2024$3,689 tax · $1,328,300 assessed
• 2023$3,543 tax · $1,288,600 assessed
• 2022$9,377 tax · $1,076,700 assessed
• 2021$8,719 tax · $1,076,700 assessed
• 2020$5,769 tax · $1,076,700 assessed
• 2018$5,375 tax · $935,600 assessed
• 2017$5,375 tax · $935,600 assessed
• 2016$6,347 tax · $1,062,300 assessed

Home value

$2,673,300

• Cotality$2,673,300
• Quantarium$2,664,311
• Collateral Analytics$2,728,000

Where it is