About this home

VR Pricing. Seller is considering offers between $375,000 and $425,000. 5596 Genesee Street is an extremely unique property that is perfect for an extremely unique buyer! Two metal buildings, almost one and a half acres of land, unlimited possibilities. The larger building, a 68 x 36 Morton pole barn is in excellent condition and has been converted into a 3 bedroom ranch home with one full bathroom, laundry room, huge great room and full kitchen. The smaller barn is a 32 x 20 steel building perfect for storage uses, warehouse uses, vehicle parking, you name it! Zoned A-R, the Town of Lancaster allows agricultural activities, beekeeping, forestry, kennels, small animal hospital, picnic groves, place of worship, and so much more! You'll find an abundance of residential, commercial, and parking space to suit all aspects of your unique needs. Listed as both SFR MLS B1723568 and COM Public record square footage includes both buildings-house & garage.

Facts and features

Schools

• Lancaster High School

  high · 9-12 · 1.3 mi

  10

• Lancaster Middle School

  middle · 7-8 · 3.6 mi

  4

• William Street School

  elementary · 4-6 · 4.7 mi

  6

• Buffalo Suburban Christian Academy

  elementary · K-8 · 0.1 mi

• Nativity Of Mary School

  elementary · K-8 · 1.6 mi

• Hillview Elementary School

  elementary · K-3 · 2.1 mi

  8

Price history

• Oct 30, 2026 · Listed$375,000
• Aug 14, 2026 · Listing Removed$419,000
• Jul 30, 2026 · Listing Removed—
• Jun 29, 2026 · Price Changed$419,000
• Jun 15, 2026 · Listed$429,900
• Mar 21, 2024 · Sold$290,000
• Apr 5, 2013 · Sold$115,000

Tax history

• 2026$3,468 tax · $130,000 assessed
• 2025$3,415 tax · $130,000 assessed
• 2024$3,353 tax · $130,000 assessed
• 2023$3,398 tax · $130,000 assessed
• 2022$3,294 tax · $130,000 assessed
• 2021$3,262 tax · $130,000 assessed
• 2020$2,737 tax · $61,000 assessed
• 2018$1,901 tax · $61,000 assessed

Home value

$370,072

• Quantarium$370,072
• Collateral Analytics$549,000

Where it is