About this home

Tucked away on just over two beautifully landscaped acres in desirable North Haven, this thoughtfully renovated residence offers an exceptional combination of privacy, comfort, and effortless Hamptons living. Nestled behind Lovelady Park and just moments from Sag Harbor Village and the Shelter Island ferry, the property enjoys a peaceful, secluded setting surrounded by mature trees and expansive lawns. Comprehensively renovated in 2025, the four-bedroom, four-bathroom home features beautifully refinished hardwood floors, freshly painted interiors, and light-filled living spaces designed for both everyday comfort and entertaining. The newly appointed chef's kitchen features custom cabinetry, high-end appliances, and a breakfast bar. An adjoining breakfast area overlooks the lush grounds, while the inviting living room with fireplace opens directly to the outdoor entertaining areas. A separate den with an additional fireplace provides a comfortable space for gathering or relaxing. Three generously proportioned guest bedrooms are conveniently located on the main level, including a junior primary suite with its own bathroom with radiant heated floor and direct access to the back yard. Upstairs, the entire second level is dedicated to a serene primary sanctuary. This spacious retreat features a cozy gas fireplace, a separate oversized closet and dressing area, and a luxurious bathroom with radiant heated floors, a freestanding soaking tub, double vanity, and glass-enclosed shower. A bonus storage area off the dressing room offers an ideal space for seasonal wardrobe rotation or specialized storage. A second, larger storage area opposite the primary could be built out into an office or playroom, and sits immediately adjacent to the well-appointed, fourth full bathroom. Outdoors, the property's park-like grounds create a truly private sanctuary. Sweeping lawns, established landscaping, and mature trees surround the heated saltwater gunite pool and expansive stone patio, offering an idyllic setting for summer relaxation and entertaining. A covered porch and adjoining outdoor dining terrace provide inviting spaces for alfresco gatherings overlooking the serene landscape. Offering the perfect balance of privacy, beautifully updated interiors, and a coveted North Haven location just minutes from Sag Harbor Village, Shelter Island, and the surrounding waterfront, this turnkey retreat captures the essence of relaxed Hamptons living.

Facts and features

Schools

• Sag Harbor Elementary School

  elementary · K-5 · 2.3 mi

  8

• Pierson Middle High School

  middle · 6-12 · 2.5 mi

  8

• HARBOR WALDORF SCHOOL

  elementary · PK-K · 2.7 mi

Price history

• Oct 20, 2026 · Listed$4,750,000
• Apr 7, 2026 · Listed$4,999,000
• Aug 23, 2024 · Sold$3,775,000
• Jun 14, 2024 · Sold$3,775,000
• Jun 6, 2000 · Sold$950,000

Tax history

• 2026$860 tax · $1,281,400 assessed
• 2025$789 tax · $1,281,400 assessed
• 2024$1,475 tax · $1,281,400 assessed
• 2023$794 tax · $1,281,400 assessed
• 2022$8,522 tax · $1,281,400 assessed
• 2021$8,424 tax · $1,281,400 assessed
• 2020$8,277 tax · $1,281,400 assessed
• 2018$7,720 tax · $1,223,300 assessed

Home value

$4,287,700

• Cotality$4,287,700
• Collateral Analytics$6,285,000
• Quantarium$3,876,020

Where it is